December 12, 2004
Random links

On the convergence of fear, hypocrisy and fanaticism

a) Last Thursday?s (12/9/2004, A15) Wall Street Journal had a story by John Carreyrou and Ian Johnson on French Muslims:

"..France is moving to create a state-supervised foundation that will channel donations from Muslims overseas and a state university curriculum to educate imams in French language, history and culture.

Although the government denies it, the new measures amount to a sharp break with France?s deeply ingrained tradition of secularism that forbids involvement by the state in religion ?France has long wrestled with how to integrate its growing Muslim population, estimated at 5 million to 7 million people among a population of 60 million. This fall it enacted a law that prohibits wearing religious symbols in public schools- a measure promoted as a broad ban, but that was conceived to keep Muslim girls from wearing headscarves. The state justified the ban by invoking the same secular tradition that it is now subverting, some French Muslim leaders argue.

Further muddling the government?s justification is the fact that France?s church-state separation is hardly absolute: The government and municipalities own-and are responsible for maintaining-Catholic churched built before a 1905 statute erected a wall between the religious and secular sphere.

The new measures are the latest expression of a government campaign to promote a ?French Islam? that is in harmony with France?s republican ideals and devoid of foreign theological influences. France is increasingly worried that poorly trained, mostly foreign imams who preach in mosques and prayer room across the country are spreading a radical brand of Island that can lead to terrorism and alienation from the French society. This year, it deported eight imams on the ground that they were fomenting anti-Western sentiment and violence with their sermons

..In Germany, senior politicians have called for imams to preach only in German, a demand that was amplified after a television crew filmed a Turkish-speaking imam at a Berlin mosque declaring Germans to be malodorous and unkempt infidels destined to burn in hell. The German state has set up a university-level program in Islamic theology meant to train imams?

b) Also last week, David Brooks educated the long suffering readers of New York Times Times about ?Natalism?. In that article, he introduced us to one Steve Sailer:

?As Steve Sailer pointed out in The American Conservative, George Bush carried the 19 states with the highest white fertility rates, and 25 of the top 26. John Kerry won the 16 states with the lowest rates.?

Garance Franke-Ruta deconstructed the Steve Sailer reference in this post. In a follow up post, he gave a a closer look to the data presented by Brooks. (If you are a David Brooks watcher, here is a Mathew Yglesias post on another Brooks column)

c) Via Amardeep, I found this article in Times .It explains a New Line?s decision to remove references to church in an upcoming screen adaptation of Philip Pullman?s ?His Dark Materials?.

?The studio wants alterations because of fears of a backlash from the Christian Right in the United States. The changes are being made with the support of Pullman, who told The Times last year that he received ?a large amount? for the rights.?

'His Dark Materials' is (apparently) a trilogy about two kids fighting the church.

Amardeep notes:

"? It's now safer to criticize "Power" than it is to talk about individual instances of the abuse of it. It also tells us something about the dynamics of representing power on screen vs. in books. The mainstream movies can show an aesthetic of totalitarian oppression, but they can't pinpoint it with any historical precision. Historial details still matter, but only in books.?

d) In Locana, Anand remembered a day in India in Dec, 1992:

?In the days followed, people were behaving in pretty strange -- or was that more natural then? -- ways. I could see many friends of mine from the Muslim community keeping a distance from me and other non-Muslims. The behaviour of several of my Hindu friends was even more strange. Many were ecstatic about the destruction that took place in Ayodhya -- several ordinary Hindu teenagers parrotted local RSS hooligans, for a short period though. When our college reopened after a fortnight of bandhs, hartals, strikes, and a general everything-isn't-alright atmosphere, my closest friend confessed to me that though he couldn't justify Gandhi's assassination -- many on the "secular" side were talking a lot about the parallels between the Masjid demolition and Gandhi's assassination ?. As one can see, talking in extremes was the norm?. I found that those who actually work with people and their problems weren't floundering at difficult times, unlike some of the bookish liberal intellectuals. In societal matters, words of those who are willing to make sacrifices, started appealing to me more, than the dull rigour of "academic" logic.?
Posted by Kaushik at December 12, 2004 03:14 PM | TrackBack
Home
About
RandomNotes is the placeholder for my links and thoughts on media, politics, economy, books, visual arts and pop culture in India and USA. It gets updated twice a week or so.

You can contact me at kaush at kaush.com.
Category archives
art and films
business
Connecticut
Housekeeping
Internet
media
music
personal
photography
politics
pop culture
South Asia
this and that
travel
weblogs
words
Monthly Archives
Recent Entries
Test message
Stray thoughts on building sustainable advantages in IT
Catering to the BPOs in India .....
Interview with a blog spammer
Communication history trivia
Orwell online
Death and taxes
Two Texans
More wars?
Summers does it again
Favourite places


Media

Romenesko's
Mediaah

US Politics & society (kinda)

Josh Marshall
Atrios
Oxblog
The Volokh Conspiracy
Electrolyte
Crooked Timber

World

Living in China
Southern Exposure
A fistful of Euros

The Indian diaspora

Tiffinbox
Prashant Kothari
Om Malik
Filtercoffee
Sathish
Sajit Gandhi
SlowRead
Emergic

Words

Booksluts
Caterina
Mobilives
Dale Keiger


Economy

Brad Delong
Argmax
Edward Hughes
Arnold Kling
Barry L. Ritholtz
Indian economy watch


Net, tech biz


Ventureblog
Oligopoly watch
Landscape of capital
Joi Ito

Anil Dash
Mark Pilgrim
Field notes
Bill Thompson
Gillmor

Filter
Politech
Crypto-gram
Interesting people


Visual arts

Greg.org
Modernartnotes
Thomas Locke Hobbs
Consumptive

PDN
National Geographic
Photography-guide
Gabrielle de Montmollin's
Vincent LAforet's
Artkrush
NikonNet

Kitsch

Metafilter
Technorati
Doonsbury
Syndicate this site (XML)
Powered by
Movable Type 3.35