June 11, 2003
The increasing disillusionment about Iraq

I don?t intend to write regularly, or at great length about Iraq. I also suspect that only by 2008 would US may debate more earnestly and objectively about this particular misadventure. For now, I just plan to jot down from time to time, my impressions of what has been catching my interest.

I have been following the unfolding ?Who is Salam Pax?? story a tad obsessively. Many may had already read the Guardian news story which finally identified Salam Pax as a 29-year-old Iraqi architect. Incidentally, he is also writing a fortnightly column
in The Guardian.

Peter Mass was one of the Western journalists working in Iraq who was getting requests to look up Salam Pax while he was there. When he got back to the States and got down to actually reading up Salam?s weblog, he realized that Salam Pax has also been working as an interpreter for foreign journalists in Iraq. He thought it funny that both Salam Pax and him have been moving around in the same circles. He read further and it slowly dawned on him that Salam Pax has been his own interpreter in Iraq! ( Story here).

There is some conservative anger directed at Salam largely because he is being equally dismissive of the new American administration as he has been of Saddam?s. I wonder when would people figure out, that from an every day life perspective, food, safety and basic utilities are at least as important as that elusive ?thingy? called ?freedom?.

Salam Pax caught the imagination of people here largely because he is the only Iraqi commoner with a Western mind, writing on the net in an interesting way. The Iraq debate on the weblog space has largely been about Western men arguing with each other about the morality and/or logistics of intervention in Iraq. There are very few genuine Iraqi voices at the fray. Those that are there are so clothed in religiosity and / or fundamentalism of some hue or other that people elsewhere can?t relate to them. Salam Pax represents is the kind of people America wanted to liberate. So his enthusiasm for the intervention gave emotional vindication to the conservatives. Now that he is turning bitter about the occupation, those folks are feeling betrayed.

The other interesting thing to watch has been the constant leaks from the intelligence agencies on both sides of the Atlantic. The most palatable explanation of the leaks coming out of UK and USA is that the US and British administrations grossly exaggerated the risks of WMD from Saddam. Guradian has a very good summary of the story so far. Timothy Gorton Ash in an interesting essay said that 'distorted intelligence on Iraq is part of an Orwellian world of fabricated reality'.

The question that conservatives are posing is, do we care? Considering the regular discovery mass graves in Iraq, of children buried alive, of men killed at gunpoints, I don?t think anyone disputes that the world is well rid of Saddam. It does leave a very bitter taste in mouth though, that the US and British administrations deliberately mislead, or at best grossly exaggerated, the threats posed by Saddam?s Iraq. That by itself would not have mattered much if the US government seemed genuinely committed to Iraq. Where I come from, I have very low expectations from politicians. Disinformation or lies by this administration, whatever you may choose to call it, does not shock me greatly any more.

To me, the more important question has always been, would this government make enough of a commitment, to create in Iraq, a just, humane and prosperous society. Most liberals have always felt that this administration does not have the patience and inclination for nation building. And I must admit that the post war management of Iraq is so incredibly badly handled that you have to agree. There is only a very small window that you get when you have so much good will that you can make magic happen. I suspect that window of opportunity is running out in Iraq and the air of empire building rather than nation building has slowly been pervading the airwaves.

Let me wrap up with some good news about the looted treasures from the Iraqi museum.

Posted by Kaushik at June 11, 2003 05:46 PM | TrackBack
Comments

Now they work. Thanks.

Posted by: Kaushik on June 13, 2003 7:27 AM

Some of the links you have given here are incorrect. the guardian link point here -

http://www.kaush.com/%E2%80%9Chttp://www.guardian.co.uk/Iraq/dailybriefing/story/0,12965,973118,00.html%E2%80%9D

and it gives a 404 on clicking.

Gorton Ash essay points here - http://www.kaush.com/%E2%80%9Dhttp://www.guardian.co.uk/comment/story/0,3604,970452,00.html%E2%80%9D
and this too gives a 404

Posted by: Buban on June 12, 2003 5:56 AM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?



Home
About
RandomNotes is the placeholder for my links and thoughts on media, politics, economy, books, visual arts and pop culture in India and USA. It gets updated twice a week or so.

You can contact me at kaush at kaush.com.
Category archives
art and films
business
Connecticut
Housekeeping
Internet
media
music
personal
photography
politics
pop culture
South Asia
this and that
travel
weblogs
words
Monthly Archives
Recent Entries
Test message
Stray thoughts on building sustainable advantages in IT
Catering to the BPOs in India .....
Interview with a blog spammer
Communication history trivia
Orwell online
Death and taxes
Two Texans
More wars?
Summers does it again
Favourite places


Media

Romenesko's
Mediaah

US Politics & society (kinda)

Josh Marshall
Atrios
Oxblog
The Volokh Conspiracy
Electrolyte
Crooked Timber

World

Living in China
Southern Exposure
A fistful of Euros

The Indian diaspora

Tiffinbox
Prashant Kothari
Om Malik
Filtercoffee
Sathish
Sajit Gandhi
SlowRead
Emergic

Words

Booksluts
Caterina
Mobilives
Dale Keiger


Economy

Brad Delong
Argmax
Edward Hughes
Arnold Kling
Barry L. Ritholtz
Indian economy watch


Net, tech biz


Ventureblog
Oligopoly watch
Landscape of capital
Joi Ito

Anil Dash
Mark Pilgrim
Field notes
Bill Thompson
Gillmor

Filter
Politech
Crypto-gram
Interesting people


Visual arts

Greg.org
Modernartnotes
Thomas Locke Hobbs
Consumptive

PDN
National Geographic
Photography-guide
Gabrielle de Montmollin's
Vincent LAforet's
Artkrush
NikonNet

Kitsch

Metafilter
Technorati
Doonsbury
Syndicate this site (XML)
Powered by
Movable Type 3.35