May 07, 2003
The Jayson Blair affair

On a letter posted in the Romanesko forum on 4/30/03, Bill Cook summed up the last few months' damage:

--NY Times photographer leaves paper amid controversy over allegations he staged newsphoto --LA Times photographer fired over altered photo --CNN admits years after the fact they suppressed certain stories from Iraq because they feared Iraqi government retaliation --Reporters busted trying to bring 'war souvenirs' from Iraq into U.S. --Pulitzer prize winning reporter Peter Arnett fired by MSNBC after he gives interview to Iraqi government TV --Fox News reporter Geraldo Rivera (and others) kicked out of Iraq by military after revealing too much info about U.S. troop movements --Two Salt Lake City Tribune reporters fired after admitting they were paid $20,000 by the National Enquirer for info on the Elizabeth Smart case --San Antonio Express editor complains after NY Times prints story that has portions that are similar to a story that ran in the Express .....

Today, in a devastating analysis of the Jayson Blair affair published in Washington City Paper, Erik Wemple and Josh Levin provided a more nuanced analysis:

When it comes to correcting itself, the Times is a two-tiered institution. The correction desk at the paper is legendary for its thoroughness. Anyone who takes a look at its daily work?the paper's Page A2 corrections box?cannot avoid the conclusion that the paper of record is serious about its job. The box picks apart every sentence of the erring reporter's work and pointedly restates the mistakes?all of which makes for interesting reading. Compared with the Post, says Slate magazine Editor At Large Jack Shafer, "The New York Times is more responsive about being accountable about errors of fact." (Shafer is a former editor of the City Paper.)

At a less perspicacious publication, Blair might not have acquired such a grotesque corrections archive.

Yet Blair's sniper coverage appears to hit the paper's mea culpa weak spot: 'fessing up to mistakes in coverage trends. Whether it's correspondent Walter Duranty's brushing off the famines that killed millions in the Soviet Union in the '30s or the late-'90s stories that overstated the U.S. espionage case against scientist Wen Ho Lee, the Times resists acknowledging that its coverage ever goes off track......

No probe, however, will excuse the full-system breakdown that permitted Blair to tarnish American journalism. Where were the line editors with the questions about the alleged interrogation videotape? Didn't anyone ask how this kid parachuted into Maryland and suddenly corralled a breathtaking scoop? "There's no system that I know of that can protect you from a reporter or editor who sets out to make up untrue things and get them into the paper," says Raines.

More pertinently, isn't it time that NYT appoints an ombudsman?

(More later)

Posted by Kaushik at May 07, 2003 08:01 AM | TrackBack
Comments
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?



Home
About
RandomNotes is the placeholder for my links and thoughts on media, politics, economy, books, visual arts and pop culture in India and USA. It gets updated twice a week or so.

You can contact me at kaush at kaush.com.
Category archives
art and films
business
Connecticut
Housekeeping
Internet
media
music
personal
photography
politics
pop culture
South Asia
this and that
travel
weblogs
words
Monthly Archives
Recent Entries
Test message
Stray thoughts on building sustainable advantages in IT
Catering to the BPOs in India .....
Interview with a blog spammer
Communication history trivia
Orwell online
Death and taxes
Two Texans
More wars?
Summers does it again
Favourite places


Media

Romenesko's
Mediaah

US Politics & society (kinda)

Josh Marshall
Atrios
Oxblog
The Volokh Conspiracy
Electrolyte
Crooked Timber

World

Living in China
Southern Exposure
A fistful of Euros

The Indian diaspora

Tiffinbox
Prashant Kothari
Om Malik
Filtercoffee
Sathish
Sajit Gandhi
SlowRead
Emergic

Words

Booksluts
Caterina
Mobilives
Dale Keiger


Economy

Brad Delong
Argmax
Edward Hughes
Arnold Kling
Barry L. Ritholtz
Indian economy watch


Net, tech biz


Ventureblog
Oligopoly watch
Landscape of capital
Joi Ito

Anil Dash
Mark Pilgrim
Field notes
Bill Thompson
Gillmor

Filter
Politech
Crypto-gram
Interesting people


Visual arts

Greg.org
Modernartnotes
Thomas Locke Hobbs
Consumptive

PDN
National Geographic
Photography-guide
Gabrielle de Montmollin's
Vincent LAforet's
Artkrush
NikonNet

Kitsch

Metafilter
Technorati
Doonsbury
Syndicate this site (XML)
Powered by
Movable Type 3.35